ATERRA's 'update' cuts its copper resource 5.5% in five weeks. PMET's NPV triples on a spodumene price 28% above the consensus it cites
Three numbers that sound bigger than they are: an all inferred copper gold resource that shrank and tests its pits at US$6 copper, a lithium feasibility study rebuilt on a 46% higher price deck, and an antimony exploration target graded above almost every hole that supports it.
November 10, 2026 at 5:35 p.m. EST · 3 min read

Under the Glass reads the assumptions behind resource and study headlines. This week: ATERRA, PMET Resources and Critical One. Company figures come from their releases; market prices are cited separately; our own math is labelled.
ATERRA: smaller, still 100% inferred
ATERRA Metals (CSE: ATC) headlined an update to its Totora resource in Chile and the filing of a technical report. The resource is "150.1 million tonnes" at "0.305% copper" and "0.159 grams per tonne" gold, or 0.517% copper equivalent, containing "1,009 million pounds" of copper and "768.7 thousand troy ounces" of gold. "The resource estimate remains classified entirely as Inferred."
The release's own comparison table shows what the headline does not say. Against the estimate announced on September 24, 2026:
- Tonnes: 159.8 million to 150.1 million, down 6.1%.
- Contained copper: 1,067.3 to 1,009.0 million pounds, down 5.5%.
- Contained gold: 792.9 to 768.7 thousand ounces, down 3.0%.
- Contained copper equivalent: 1,790.8 to 1,710.5 million pounds, down 4.5%.
Two price decks sit in the same release. "The updated conceptual open-pit shells use a copper price of US$6.00/lb", while the copper equivalent calculation uses "US$4.00/lb copper and US$3,650/oz gold." Copper was about US$6.29 a pound on November 10, according to MetalCharts, so the pit shell price sits close to spot. The point is the gap inside the release: the shells that support "reasonable prospects" use a copper price 50% higher than the one used to state the grade, by our arithmetic.
PMET: the price deck did the work
PMET Resources (TSX: PMET) was halted at 4:24 p.m. ET on Tuesday pending news, then released an "enhanced" CV5 lithium tantalum feasibility study in Quebec: "After-tax NPV8% of ~CA$5.10B (US$3.72B) and IRR of ~40.4%" at a "long-term spodumene price of US$1,788/t."
The release's comparison with its 2025 feasibility study:
- Spodumene price: US$1,221 a tonne to US$1,788, up 46%.
- After tax NPV: CA$1,594 million to CA$5,100 million.
- IRR: 18.1% to 40.4%.
- Phase 1 initial capital net of credits: CA$1,247.7 million to CA$1,260.4 million.
Capital barely moved; the price assumption did. The same release also gives an "After-tax NPV8% of ~CA$3.29B (US$2.40B) at near broker consensus spodumene pricing of ~US$1,400/t." By our arithmetic, the base case price is about 28% above the consensus figure the company itself cites, and that difference is worth about CA$1.8 billion of NPV.
Two smaller points. The text gives a mine life of "approximately 20 years"; Table 2 gives 19. And the dateline reads Montreal, November 10, over a body that opens with November 11, 2026 and Sydney, Australia. In PMET's favour: reserves are probable only and based on indicated material, and the release says inferred material inside the pit has "been treated as waste."
PMET announced the same afternoon that its CEO will move to executive chair once a successor is found.
Critical One: a target graded above its holes
Critical One Energy (CSE: CRTL) reported that "Micon has outlined an exploration target for Howells Lake of 2 to 6 million tonnes grading 3% to 8% antimony." The release states that "The potential quantity and grade of the exploration target is conceptual in nature" and gives no effective date.
The drilling in the same release: HWL-2026-021 cut "4.0 m grading 4.52% Sb, including 2.0 m at 7.96% Sb" and "2.0 m grading 3.93% Sb." HWL-2026-022 returned "13.0 m grading 0.59% Sb" and "5.42 m grading 1.66% Sb." HWL-2026-023 returned "5.0 m grading 1.66% Sb, including 2.0 m at 3.10% Sb." By our arithmetic, only the short intervals in one hole, plus one two metre include, reach the low end of the target grade range; the longest intercept reported runs at about a fifth of it. An exploration target is not a resource, and this one rests on a few metres. We covered the company's C$425 million offtake MOU on October 30.
Sources
More from the Mining Desk
Under the Glass: RUA's Auld Creek study loses US$30.5 million at US$3,700 gold. Bonterra's Barry PEA uses US$3,500
Mining Desk · 10h ago

Starcore's 'second quarter' production report covers one month. Clinch calls its first producing quarter a record
Mining Desk · 10h ago

G Mining is 'on track' with year to date costs above its range. Americas Gold and Silver's record quarter cost US$42.94 an ounce against a US$35 ceiling
Mining Desk · 4d ago
