Listed Ledger
Deal Check

Catalyst One's 'arm's length' vendor becomes a 15.3% insider. Trinity owes 78% of its price in year four, and two partners print different acceleration clauses

Five property deals, no resources. A vendor that keeps a 3% royalty through an affiliate, a tungsten project with two names and no share price, a four year balloon option, a hydrogen option described two ways, and a royalty sale headlined as option funding.

Deals Desk

November 6, 2026 at 5:25 p.m. EST · 3 min read

In this story
Geologist in the field. Stock photo, not a property named in this article.
Geologist in the field. Stock photo, not a property named in this article. Photo: Magnific.

Five property deals this week. None of the properties carries a resource. So the questions are the usual ones: what is really being paid, when, to whom, and what is left over for shareholders once the royalty holder is fed.

Catalyst One: "arm's length," then an insider

Catalyst One (TSXV: CATX) agreed to buy a BC rare earth property from LIRECA Resources for "aggregate cash and share consideration of $870,000": "3,800,000 common shares" "at a deemed price of $0.15" and "$300,000 in cash." By our arithmetic the shares are C$570,000 of the total.

The release says "The Vendor is at arm's length to the Company," and in the same document that the vendor "will become an "Insider" of the Company" with "approximately 15.3%." A "3% net smelter returns royalty" goes to "1079170 B.C. Ltd., an affiliate of the Vendor." It can be cut "from 3% to 1%, in 1% increments" by paying "US$1,000,000 for each 1% reduction," so by our arithmetic US$2 million buys back two thirds of it and the last 1% is permanent. The property "is being explored for REE and niobium"; there is no resource. "No finder's fee is payable."

Torrent Gold: Sunset or Sunrise, and at what price

Torrent Gold (CSE: TGLD) agreed to buy a tungsten project in Hidalgo County, New Mexico for "a cash payment of Cdn$100,000" and "3,500,000 common shares." The release states no deemed price for the shares, so the total cost cannot be computed from it. The headline calls it the Sunset project; the body calls it the "Sunrise Tungsten Project." A "1.5% net smelter returns royalty" applies, of which 0.75% can be bought back "within ten years of closing, for a one-time cash payment of US$1,000,000." No sampling, grades or historical production are given for the 19 claims.

Trinity Silver: US$10 million, mostly later

Trinity Silver (TSXV: TOM) received conditional TSXV approval to option the historic Chañarcillo area in Chile for "total consideration of USD $10-million in cash." The schedule: US$150,000 at signing, $300,000 at 12 months, $750,000 at 24, $1 million at 36 and "$7.8-million at 48 months." By our arithmetic 78% of the price is due in year four, which makes this a four year option with a large balloon, not a purchase. A one year extension costs "USD $2-million, which is creditable against the final" payment.

Get the CATX, TGLD, TOM, MEK, BEX, JG alert

We email you the moment CATX, TGLD, TOM, MEK, BEX, JG puts out news, files, or shows up in our coverage. Free, and one click to stop.

The royalty terms include "a minimum royalty of USD $200 per year." We quote the figure exactly as printed; on a US$10 million deal it reads like a missing digit, and the company should confirm it. A "2.0% net smelter return royalty" applies from commercial production. "No finder's fees were paid."

Metals Creek and Benton: same deal, two releases, two meanings

Metals Creek (TSXV: MEK) and Benton Resources (TSXV: BEX) each announced an option of their Bay of Islands natural hydrogen licences in western Newfoundland to Brutus Mining. The economics match: $100,000 cash over two years and 1,200,000 Brutus shares "at a deemed price per Share of $0.76," which by our arithmetic is C$912,000 of stock, plus "3% Gross Metals Returns," half redeemable "for a $1,000,000 payment." There is no dollar work commitment.

The wording on acceleration differs. The Metals Creek release says "The Company may accelerate any cash payment or Share issuance at its election." The Benton release, issued about two hours later, says "Brutus may accelerate." Read inside Metals Creek's own release, "the Company" is Metals Creek, which would make no sense for a payment Metals Creek receives. It is probably a drafting slip, but a clause about who controls the payment timetable should read the same in both versions. The property is "considered favourable for potentially hosting natural hydrogen"; there are no results yet.

Japan Gold: "option funding" that is a royalty sale

Japan Gold (TSXV: JG) headlined "Japan Gold Receives OR Royalties Option Funding." The body describes an outright sale: it "received US$3 million from OR Royalties Inc." "to acquire an additional 0.5% net smelter return royalty" "on all Japan Gold properties," and "OR Royalties' royalty interest has increased from 1.5% to a total of 2.0%." By our arithmetic that prices each 1% of royalty at US$6 million.

The chief executive calls it "non-dilutive capital." For shareholders it is not dilutive in shares, but every future ounce from any Japan Gold property now carries a 2% royalty to one holder. The money goes to properties "outside the Solidcore Alliance," to "expand drilling capacity" and to working capital.

All figures are from the linked releases.

Get market-moving alerts

The news releases, deals and filings that move stocks on the TSX, TSXV, CSE, Nasdaq and NYSE, the moment they land. Free.

More from the Deals Desk